Noah Stone has been obsessed with the same girl, Kara Bates, for over five years, and she has him tightly wrapped around her finger. Adam Klein is Noah's roommate and childhood friend who signs him up for Jewish online dating (JewDate) to get him over Kara, out of his rut and on his path to finding happiness. It is a journey wrought with surprises, both pleasurable and extremely painful, but always hilarious.