When the great partnership of Dunn and Gunn ends in tragedy, Matt Gunn (Charles Struck, Jr) must decide whether to continue being a detective or walk away forever. Enter Rollie P. Ollie (Kevin Brubaker), an inexperienced would-be detective,, and Polly Anna Day (Brittney Michelle Donovan), an odd, quirky receptionist who further perplexes Matt's decision. The case of a missing girl propels the three toward a thrilling conclusion which will either bring Matt back from his old self or ruin the great detective forever.