The Joe Baccala Story is a faux documentary of an individual and his friends who have taken on the Mafioso Stereotype as their own. Using satire and comedy, the Joe Baccala Story addresses Hollywood and mass media's stereotypical portrayal of Italian Americans, pop culture and society's acceptance of the guido and mafia images, and those who take on that identity as real and incorporate it into their daily lives. Everyone around Baccala thinks he's a made guy including himself. The story is narrated by Baccala and his childhood friend Billy C from undisclosed locations.